Thank you for all the tips, especially the one about the original song! I knew about it as a vector for weird glitches, but not its actual gameplay function. As for the 20x Skulltula Token reward, unfortunately Ship of Harkinian won't make my controller rumble for some reason, but thankfully there's an option for a visual indicator (they really do have everything!) and I've already used it to find two locations that would have otherwise been impossible. Well, maybe 1.5 is more accurate...see the spoiler below.
On Secret Holes
The first one was the one right past the tree in Kakariko Village. I'd just scored my 500 rupee bag, so a cool 200 rupees was the perfect reward!
The second was in front of the entrance to Goron City, which I always thought was suspicious since even before I got the Stone of Agony I'd worked out that a circle of stones is an indication of a secret hole, but I bombed the absolute hell out of that platform to no avail. What gives? The only thing I could think of is that I need to place the bomb in such a way that I destroy all of the stones simultaneously, but the blast radius doesn't seem big enough.
Also, unfortunately save states are pretty jank in Ship of Harkinian and not officially supported (I thought I'd permanently borked my save right before the third dungeon and was panicking for a good few minutes), but they're still useful for when you need to do stuff like repeat one of the minigames without having to farm a bunch of rupees. I haven't really felt the need to use them much, thankfully.
After thinking on it, I guess one justification behind always loading you at the starting zone is the fact that
Save Location Speculation (+ a question)
the Lost Woods are connected to Goron City and Zora's Domain once you've obtained each of their respective items, so you can travel to those places relatively quickly. I haven't played any of the 2D Zeldas yet (although I'd like to!) but it's similar to the NES Super Mario Brothers titles and their warp pipes/warp whistles—there were no saves or passcodes, but a skilled player armed with game knowledge could get wherever they wanted to go pretty quickly.
Actually, speaking of the Lost Woods: can you reach Saria again after visiting her deep in the woods but before going to the Temple of Time with all the Spiritual Stones? I'd wanted to stop by just because it seemed like what I would do in Link's position, even if it doesn't actually unlock anything, but I can't seem to get back to the maze no matter how many times I try (although everyone in Kokiri Forest still assures me that Saria is there waiting for me).
I'm glad I did try, though, because I realized that 1. I'd missed some upgrades because I was skim reading the Business Scrubs' text (like I said, I'm playing in Japanese, so my skim reading skills aren't the best and I didn't realize that some are selling upgrades and not just refills) and 2. I stumbled into completing the second mask trading quest, but not before I'd also stumbled into getting a Deku Stick upgrade using said mask.
As for your extra tips:
Tips
Way ahead of you on the bean thing! I bought his entire stock out as soon as I could and I've planted all of the beans I could (still have two left).
Noted on early Lon Lon Ranch and the final cleanup. While I had heard about the Stone of Agony, I genuinely have no idea what you're referring to in terms of songs that will help with item collection, so I'm curious to find out!
And that's interesting about the 100% reward! I've heard that it's a bit tedious and that most people just go for all of the "regular" rewards (which I think requires 50/100?), but I don't actually know what the rewards are beyond maybe more wallet space and I have no idea what the 100% reward is. I guess I can save before I collect it and see what I think!
And here's where I'm at, currently:
My progress + another question
I collected the last Spiritual Stone and am basically done scouring Hyrule:
Upgrades:
- 2x Deku Sticks (30 capacity)
- 1x Deku Nuts (30 capacity)
- 2x Deku Seeds (50 capacity)
- 1x Bomb Bag (30 capacity)
- 3x Bottles
- Silver Scale
- Din's Fire
- Farore's Wind (This seems...not super useful, but maybe it'll come in handy more in the dreaded Water Temple? I've set my warp point at the entrance of Dodongo's Cavern for now.)
- First four songs
- 14x Pieces of Heart (if I've done my math right—I've got 9 hearts + 2 pieces, so accounting for the three starting and three dungeons that's (9 - 6) * 4 + 2 = 3 * 4 + 2 = 12 + 2 = 14)
- 34x Gold Skulltula Tokens (seems like the only areas I've completely cleared out are the Deku Tree, Jabu Jabu's Belly, and Lon Lon Ranch...still wondering what I missed in my second trip to Dodongo's Cavern, since I did pick up the one out-of-reach Skulltula Token that I noted on my first run—the one that becomes unreachable after you bring down the stairs with the chain of bombs—but there's clearly still at least one that I've missed. Unfortunately, I wasn't great about writing down what I collected until after Dodongo's Cavern, so I don't know how many I picked up, let alone which ones.)
I have one burning question: can I return to Hyrule Castle Town after collecting the three Spiritual Stones without locking myself out of anything? As soon as I started to approach to go and get the next mask, it triggered a cutscene, which spooked me, so I reset. I was operating under the assumption that I'd be okay until I go into the Temple of Time and do the timey-wimey thing, but I don't know if I get put on rails as soon as I let that cutscene play out. At the very least, I wanna go play my fifth song (presumably the Song of Time?) for that last frog in Zora's River!
I have no idea if it's possible to do this using only a save file, but I'd love to make a little program that will take your save file as input and tell you exactly how many Skulltulas you're missing in each area, allowing you to view individual hints relevant to your current item loadout (so it won't rob you of the opportunity to figure out things for yourself or burden you with irrelevant information). Ideally, it would be a series of increasingly specific hints to maximize the chance for the player to still feel some satisfaction for solving the puzzle. I would assume that there's a flag in the save file for each individual Skulltula so the game can check if its token has been collected to prevent it from spawning, but I haven't dug into the code yet.
Anyway, sorry for writing such a long comment! It's been quite some time since I got really immersed in a game like this, and I really appreciate the advice you've already given! I remember hearing kids at school talking about Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask when they came out, but I never saw either with my own eyes, and so I only learned about them obliquely—characters, stages, and trophies in Super Smash Bros. Melee, retrospective comparisons with later games in the series like Wind Waker and Twilight Princess (the former of which I still need to beat, and the latter of which I still need to play), speedrunning glitches, and the like. It's been so gratifying to finally get my hands on it and experience it for myself all these years later.