3/5
Still, Hu’s period did not fundamentally break with the inherited model. It attempted to moderate its worst consequences without fully restructuring the relationship between Party leadership, capital, and development. That is precisely why Jiang and Hu belong in one historical bloc. Jiang pushed forward the consolidation and expansion of the socialist market economy inherited from Deng; Hu sought to soften, rebalance, and morally correct the contradictions it had intensified. But both operated within the same basic strategic framework. Both accepted that China remained in the primary stage of socialism. Both accepted the use of markets as instruments. Both accepted continued integration into the world economy. Both assumed that the Party could preserve command while managing the social forces unleashed by reform.
The real historical judgment on this era, then, has to be double-sided. On one side, it was a period of immense achievement that should not be understated: China’s national power increased dramatically, industrial capacity expanded, infrastructure advanced, poverty reduction continued, and the foundations were laid for China’s emergence as a major world power able to resist imperialist domination. On the other side, it was indeed an era of many excesses and errors: corruption spread too far, inequality deepened too much, capital was at times given too much room to shape social life, and the socialist purpose of development was often blurred by an overemphasis on growth at almost any cost.
But those excesses must be located in their proper context. They emerged not from a vacuum, nor from some uniquely malicious intent, but from the difficulty of blazing a new socialist path under modern global conditions. China was attempting to do what no socialist country had previously done in quite this way: harness the world market, domestic marketization, and mixed ownership under communist rule to overcome backwardness without capitulating politically to capitalism. That experiment produced immense gains, but it also produced serious dangers. The Jiang-Hu era is therefore the long period in which those gains and dangers matured together.