I know you're still thinking about preserving Noam Chomsky's good name when you say all that.
Now go back and reread everything you wrote but apply it to teenage-raper Jeffrey epstein. Oh never mind that he raped teenage girls. He was such a brilliant financier. Which shall we remember him by? Both equally? But doesn't one bad deed overpower all the good?
Good people go to prison for doing one bad thing. It happens all the time. Should we set them free because they're good at philosophy or art or accounting?
In my personal life, my dad committed suicide in 1996. I was a Daddy's girl and I loved him and we had such a good times all the 21 years I was in his life but every time I think of him there's a darkness that overshadows it all because he committed suicide and that overshadows everything and I wish it wouldn't. One moment of him killing himself overshadowed his 46 years of productive life & people loved him. Yes one bad thing can indeed overshadow an entire life of good. Can you put that into perspective?