Reminds me of this:

I think atproto is a good protocol, but god bluesky-the-company is dogshit.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 1 point 11 months ago (2 children)

Just to play Devil's Advocate, since I am a huge fan of Filoni's Clone Wars series, Clanker feels the most weird because it was created to be used as a slur in the same way the Allied forces had slurs for Germans and Japanese in WW2. I can understand why some people might have moral grounds against using what is ultimately a proxy of real life slurs, especially if they were ever a recipient of that kinda discrimination. Sure, it's a fantasy, and I think from a standpoint of "The Republic is experiencing moral decay" it's interesting for the story, but it was always a lil fucked up that the kids show thought hurling slurs was such a fundamental part of war that they needed to invent a new one. It'd probably be better if we didn't teach children that.

It's also kinda a weird slur to use against AI. The droids are called clankers because they clank, it's like an onomotopeia. LLMs don't clank at all.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 11 months ago

    (This comment is not really a criticism)

    you would not be the first person to look at the etymology of a slur, note that it originally had a different context, and point out that it doesn’t really map 1:1 with its usage.

    having not watched the clone wars I can’t comment on specifics with your example.

    Anyway, regarding slurs against non-sentient things: “Lemon”, “hunkajunk”, “shitbox” get used for cars, i demand justice for cars!!!

  • source
  • parent