I've lived my whole life in Saskatchewan on Daylight time. It's fine. Everyone else in Saskatchewan that I know is fine. The changing clocks is worse than staying on Daylight time.
post
Maybe, maybe not, but they are 100% right choosing to stop this clock changing nonsense.
Yeah, I'd like to see a comparison of switching to permanent DST and continuing with the twice-annual changes.
Manitoba is on the eastern side of their timezone. They aren't getting hours of dark in the morning by doing this, they are getting sunlight at 5pm.
-"In the dead of winter, sunrise might not happen until close to 9 a.m., which means "young people who are going to school are going to have to do so in pure darkness," and that has potential health implications, Mak said.
The light people are exposed to in the morning stabilizes the body's circadian rhythm β the natural 24-hour internal clock that regulates sleep-wake cycles and other biological processes.
"[It] gives us better mood and better energy. So we're going to see an amplification of disturbed nighttime sleep, reduced total sleep time," said Mak, clinical vice-president of the Canadian Sleep Society."-
Its one friggin hour. So people are going to get so much morning sun if its perm st over dst. the only thing I see here is think of the children but you know society determines the start and stop time of the school day. Honsetly the whole thing is silly as we are the ones deciding when to get up and start things. rather than dst how about we just change our schedules when we want to.
I go to work AND go home from work in the dark in the winter even with the time change. If we stay on daylight time, I might actually see the sun after work.
Edit: I leave for work at 7:10 AM and I see all the neighbourhood kids already outside waiting for the school bus. So even with the time change they are going to school in the dark. Making it one hour earlier wonβt make a difference.
thats what I kind of mean. Its like fine we can do st but then make 8-4 the typical day or whatever. its like either way I prefer to have a bit of sun at some point.
When I was in school we walked in the dark I winter. And come on no one is walking to school these days everyone gets driven.
Even if this is a real issue, its not like we cant do something like use special lighting in schools for the start of the day. Might cost something to set up, but its possible.
they are talking about getting to school. so dangerous for walking/biking/waiting for transit. Again though they decide when the school day starts and ends. They don't need to change everyone elses clock for it.
When school starts is more about the standard 9-5 workday. Parents need to be able to drop the kids off and then get to work. We could absolutely change it, but we'd also need to change the workday.
The start time is often not a match for sleep cycles of children over the various ages, but about the work schedule.
I still see that as something that workplaces should just do then. One of the enshitification things that annoys me is in the 90's you had this thing with businesses where you could start at a time you wanted withing a sliding window and then work 8.5 hours from there. A place I was at did 7am to 10am and then meetings took place between 10am and 3pm when everyone was sure to be there. Was great for avoiding rush hour. Feels like these things are like bussiness people fads then they chase the next thing. Honestly I don't see how the adult work day makes much of a difference given the schoolday is shorter than the workday. Parents have to work that stuff out anyway.
Big deal. Just means waking up an hour earlier in the winter and actually having some sunlight at the end of the day.
Right, why should we care about kids walking to school in darkness?
It's been shown time and time again that waking up later is better for learning and for health, and yet we keep forcing everyone to wake as early as possible because we associate sleeping with laziness.
I wonder if those experts are familiar with the expression "the perfect is the enemy of the good."
I have lived in Saskatchewan my whole life time changes have affected me a whole whopping two times, both where because tech things thought I was in the Manitoba time zone and I thought I was an hour late for something when they fell back or sprange forward.
There's now more daylight for winter camping. This is a total game changer to me
Where I live in BC, people literally stop camping the day the clocks go back

all 30 comments