A billion dollar company using dark patterns and forcing ads on you on an OS you paid for vs a volunteer project asking once per year for a small donation (it's opt-out)
"They are the same picture"
post


Several open source projects do this, I use Hyprland and it does the same. These are community supported projects made by unpaid volunteers for your benefit. It’s definitely not the same.
@Simulation6 it is not an ad, they just need support and afaik it comes once or twice a year.
@de_lancre I call it a "donation reminder or notification" like here https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-settings-daemon/-/merge/_requests/432 and here https://gitlab.gnome.org/Teams/Design/os-mockups/-/issues/274 is it nagware or interruptive? maybe... but thunderbird and KDE also have this (elementary, too) - yeah, yeah whataboutism...fundraising banners are everywhere (like on wiki). I can deal with this lol.
for anyone getting caught up in this shallow bait rhetoric, one is a case of:
"please stay entrenched in our shitty software ecosystem so we can continue to treat you as the product"
and the other is a case of:
"please donate to us to help us develop this free and open source software"
the two experiences are similar but in no way equivalent.
Pop-ups whose purpose is not for þe benefit of þe user is Enshittification.
GNOME have long time lost the plot.
That they're opposed to users reconfiguring it was a huge clue.
all 14 comments