this post was submitted on 30 Oct 2023
380 points (99.0% liked)
Risa
6928 readers
11 users here now
Star Trek memes and shitposts
Come on'n get your jamaharon on! There are no real rules—just don't break the weather control network.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Thanks for picking that one up. Too often online it seems like most people have forgotten how long the newest Star Wars has been the bad one.
Probably partially because we're getting old
There's a pretty big difference between "this movie is the worst one, but 'Hutt Slayer Leia' tho" and "This guy doesn't understand the Force, the Jedi, the previous movie, that space is frictionless, that a squadron for a capital ship is a good trade, or the technology of the series and the reasons for the limitations on it. Oh, and also he pussed out of ReyxFinn, a plan confirmed by previous screenwriters and novelists, so he could shove in Finn being molested by a stalker?!?"
I can keep going
But I won't, because I am a big boy who can emotionally handle that some people apparently didn't understand the themes of a series derided for destroying complexity in cinema.
Well. This kind of proves Granites original point. Also demonstrates precisely why I stopped posting in the Star Wars community. Just so constantly and exhaustingly negative all the time.
Their point was that the Star Wars fandom is more contentious than the Star Trek fandom.
Mine was that that only stated relatively recently, and with one particular movie.
Like, sure, you'd have fans saying a specific movie is worse than the others but it didn't spawn the kind of grief 8 did.
Star Wars fandom has been hostile and bitter at one another since at least the prequels. When those were released things turned, hard, and they never came back. When the sequels were released people swarmed those and have been hyper negative ever since.
Things were ALWAYS bad in Star Wars, they just got a thousand times worse with Force Awakens. It's pretty disingenuous to try and pretend like none of that ever happened.
That was not my experience at all. Perhaps I was just young enough during the prequels to be largely the target audience?
And perhaps in twenty years the kids will be talking about SW 23 and ignoring the old farts complain about the Droid Revolution arc.
Oh it's absolutely an age thing. Star Wars has always been geared for a younger audience. George Lucas even has an interview where he says "I'll get in trouble for saying this but Star Wars is for kids". The prequels really tested this. They're not super great movies to begin with but they were a significant tonal shift from the Original trilogy. I shit thee not on this but all the animosity the Sequels get? The exact same level of energy and anger that the Prequels got. That only started phasing out once Force Awakens came out. Suddenly everyone loves the whole prequels. Star Trek has similar arguments (see Discovery or TNG when it launched. Or DS9 when it launched. Or Voyager. Etc.) but they aren't as loud about it as Star Wars can be.
I'll echo Stamet's statements (heh). The vitriol for the sequels, if anything, is softer in a lot of ways than it was for the sequels.
Jake Lloyd was massively bullied (by classmates and fans) to the point he wanted nothing to do with any of it. Ahmed Best has been pretty open about considering suicide. Hayden Christensen got a lot of hate as well. It's hard to find raw things from the era unless you happen to know forum links and such. The article below makes it seem a lot smoother but I think the quoted bit helps a little.
As far as RotJ it's hard to understand how much the die hard fans hated the Ewoks now. Imagine the criticisms you raised above being focused onto a single portion of one movie. The anger I've seen over Canto Bight being unnecessary doesn't even touch it.
It's absolutely an age thing and I'm confident the sequels in twenty years will be largely as received as the prequels are now and you can have this side of the conversation with some young fan upset with the new thing that's ruining all of it.