This is the fediverse, so this is probably going to be extremely unpopular, but yea here goes.

Not saying you have to love it, or trust it blindly. Skepticism is healthy. But there’s a difference between “I use it carefully and check everything” and “I refuse to touch it.”

Historically, refusing new tools has never stopped them. Coopers didn’t stop the steel drum by refsuing to make them. They just ended up out of work while the industry moved on.

The realistic threat isn’t AI replacing you. It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster. And the skill of using it properly (knowing when it’s wrong, veriyfing output, knowing what not to use it for) takes time to build. Starting late means competing with people who’ve had years of practice.

You can have legit concenrs about ethics, energy, or jobs and still learn the tool. Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

PS. Ethically trained models exist and you can run models locally.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 8 points 12 hours ago* (6 children)

Literally every single study I have seen on that topic has also had the same exact problem.

It assumes a person will not replace the saved time with any other skill. That they will proceed to not research, learn or engage in any other activity at all.

Every single time that gets accounted for those studies are proven flat out wrong.

Fundamentally those studies are right in the sense that yes, if you don't use your mind and you don't use your brain, you don't exercise it. You go stupid.

People overwhelmingly will do something else and develop a different skill if a tool or a utility makes a previously hard task suddenly easy.

Yes, people will lose certain computer skills. That just means that they now have the available time and resources to work on other skills.

Some people are going to be lazy pieces of s*** and not. But that's true of every time. Anything is made easier.

It's the same argument you could have against the very concept of a user interface.

The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they're rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 6 hours ago

    The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they’re rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

    You're forgetting one thing: the proliferation of the GUI made computing an accessible function for people who never learned to use a CLI in the first place. It didn't make people forget how to use a terminal, it just made people who can use a terminal more valuable. AI doesn't create any such pathway because it's being used to replace the people who knew how to use a terminal, and doing so poorly.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 4 points 8 hours ago

    The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they're rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

    Guess what? They're doing just that but instead of syntax-based terminal it's a chatbot. Are we smart yet

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 9 points 12 hours ago

    People overwhelmingly will do something else and develop a different skill if a tool or a utility makes a previously hard task suddenly easy.

    The studies haven't shown this at all. Not even close. What they have shown is that AI will gradually get used more and more and more till it replaces even the most basic requirement for thought in their daily lives.

    This has absolutely no similarity to the development of the GUI. It's not one skill that gets replaced with another. It is the complete removal of critical Human thought and problem solving. EVERY skill a person does is built upon these two things, and it's being eliminated.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 6 points 12 hours ago (2 children)

    The saved time:

    Expected speedup: 24%
    Measured slowdown: 19%
    Post-task belief: 20% faster

    After the experiment ended and the timing data was up, the developers still walked away convinced AI had sped them up.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 8 hours ago (1 child)

    Metre, the group who did that study, already declared it as outdated.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 3 hours ago*

    If its the one I think it is, it was having people use AI in their workflows that weren't familiar with it yet. The people who were, did perform better, but overall because of all the people that werent it was worse.

    They re did it with people being more familiar and the results showed a modest improvement overall.

    Essentially, like all new tools and technology, it takes time to become proficient with it.

    Also, the models and tooling would have gotten better between tests unless they controlled for that too.

  • source
  • parent