This is partially me getting stuff off my chest. This post isn’t a response to, but was partially inspired by a dumpster fire of a thread from a couple days ago that appears to be deleted now.

I was lucky enough to be raised going to a Lutheran church that was “one of the good ones.” Going through confirmation was my first formalized exposure to thinking philosophically in a way public schools don’t teach. It was through the lens of the Bible, but the discussions we had were on finding our own interpretations and meanings on what’s right. It’s where I learned the phrase “sin boldly,” something I’ve internalized to this day as accepting that I can’t be perfect but to keep moving forward. At the end I had to give a faith statement and told my pastor to his face that I wasn’t certain I believed in this God guy but I liked a lot of the lessons, and he was fine with that.

I’m pretty agnostic at this point, though I wouldn’t call myself atheist, but my religious experience has pretty much always been a good one. The last time I went to church a few years ago they outright welcomed gay, trans, and other oppressed people and offered opportunities to do good in the community.

Whenever I see online atheists hating on religion, my instinct is to get defensive because my experience with it has been good. But since I became an adult it’s also become clear to me that a lot of religious people suck and use their religion as a shield and a cudgel to act hatefully. Piping up and saying “not all religious people” rings about the same as saying “not all men” though, so I usually just don’t say anything, especially in explicitly atheist spaces. But I felt a need to express my feelings, and this seemed an appropriate way to do so.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 9 points 2 days ago (4 children)

What did telling you about an unprovable judgemental god add to your education?

If you had received a similar education but without the concept of "sin" or damnation, would that education have been inferior?

I, too, was raised in religion but I cannot know how my life would be if I hadn't been indoctrinated to think less of myself (sinful) and humanity (in need of salvation) in general, I doubt you can know, either.

  • source
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 6 points 2 days ago (3 children)

    “What did telling you about an unprovable judgemental god add to your education?“

    It predisposed me to thinking deeply about the world that I would later flesh out studying philosophy in college. Asking “are the words in the Bible the literal words of God or inspired by them” planted a seed for epistemology and where knowledge comes from. Considering morals in biblical stories is just ethics. At an age when school mostly meant learning facts how to do specific things (which are good things to teach) in confirmation we were asked questions with less clear answers. We were told what our church proposed but were then immediately given the space to question that and come to our own conclusions. English class is the closest to that, but then the focus is also split on analyzing characters and writing well.

    “If you had received a similar education but without the concept of “sin” or damnation, would that education have been inferior?”

    I was raised in a church that taught damnation hasn’t really been a thing for a couple millennia so it’s not too relevant for my experience. If you take sin to mean “doing something bad” then I think any education that discusses ethics, the thinking of right and wrong, would be inferior without the concept of wrong.

    It’s true that I can’t know how things would be different if I wasn’t raised religious, but so many things (like my parents’ own upbringing) would have to change for that different possibility that I just don’t think it’s worth thinking about very much. Like I said in my original post thinking on that Martin Luther quote “sin boldly” taught me to embrace my own shortcomings rather than beat myself up for them. I don’t think religion should make someone feel lesser, and I’m sorry that was your experience.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 2 days ago (2 children)

    None of those things require religion. Philosophy can be studied without all the bullshit lies and trappings of religion. Adding in a bunch of make-believe doesn't make morality or ethics or philosophy easier to study, it just obfuscates things. Being forced to question the nonsense that you're being taught isn't as valuable as just being taught things that aren't nonsense in the first place. The only benefit you've stated to your religious upbringing is that it allowed you to become educated, but that education was poisoned with a whole bunch of irrelevant, harmful, and often downright false ideals and beliefs. The Bible has some good messages sure, but it's not the only place to find those messages and they're interspersed amongst a whole bunch of outdated, hateful, horrific messages as well.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 8 hours ago (1 child)

    Religion popularized it and still does to this day. With the ills of the United States, only religion offers good social services, especially in the places where it is the most popular. It is clear by examining medieval Europe that life was much more horrible for those outside of the religious system; imagine no schooling at all. Then, the monastery was the only place where people were even allowed to study and think instead of create value for their lords. Secular life has much improved today, but if you head a little away from the richest areas and look at the working class, it's a little closer to serfdom than you might expect.

    It is easy to forget that a lot of that philosophy originated from religious debates, book clubs where the book is the bible. The philosophy that didn't arise there only existed in all the places the colonizers ran over (or parroted into racial exploitation) and consequently you likely know none of it.

    I really like Marx's view of religion as like a defence mechanism, that it is necessary for a lot of the downtrodden to survive, and is of course harmful, but the life it brings will outweigh that until capitalism is stamped out. It helps that the New Testament retconned a lot of the Old Testament.

    Being forced to question the nonsense that you're being taught isn't as valuable as just being taught things that aren't nonsense in the first place.

    It is extremely hard to ensure people aren't being taught nonsense; it is always more valuable to know to question everything. See for example the extensive whitewashing of the Civil Rights struggles of the 60s in even secular US education that are massively hurting organizing efforts today.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • This is nonsense. How do you think religion started? People thinking about how the world works. Religion is just a bunch of made up stories that people used to replace philosophy. Rather than admitting that they didn't have all the answers and continuing to think about life and the world, they made up a bunch of shit to make themselves feel better. And then it was used by people who knew better to control and oppress the ones who didn't have the will or capacity or education for ACTUAL philosophical thought.

    Religion didn't popularize philosophy or education. The lack of education was used as a cudgel by the powerful religious institutions to prey on and exploit people.

  • source
  • parent