Inspired by the downvotes on my comment in the other thread.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] -2 points 8 hours ago

You’re basically saying that Target is a criminal enterprise because the only way to buy Good and Gather products is to shop at target.

No, that's a bad analogy in several ways:

  • Good and Gather products have substitute goods available from other sources, while copyrighted works of art do not (by definition, since that's what copyright is for!).

  • Target may be the only place selling the products, but it's not controlling how you use them after the fact or what else you are or aren't allowed to do with the other things you're using those products with.

In order to to make your analogy work, you'd have to really torture it: it would be as if Good and Gather were the only brand allowed to sell (for example) frozen lasagna, and to cook it you'd have to use only a Target-brand oven, and the Target-brand oven was designed to disallow you from cooking non-Good and Gather foods in it. So you'd have to buy the Target-brand oven and the Good and Gather-brand lasagna or go without lasagna at all, because circumventing that restriction (including even by trying to make your own lasagna from scratch) would be illegal for some reason.

  • source
  • parent