I am… flummoxed by this. Cliffhangers are features, not speech? Have any of these judges ever read a book? Short chapters are features not speech? What? Under the logic of this ruling, a state could issue a ban on short chapters and cliffhangers as being too “addictive” and the Eleventh Circuit says that would pass intermediate scrutiny and be just fine.
If you want to live in a modern recreation Victorian era England and suffocate to death under a society that was far more prudish and conservative than those who came before or after it, this is a necessary tool! How else can you make people feel righteous in the reality tv of leaning into blaming addicts for the drug crisis?
To be honest I am not sure what the goal is, if this is not the goal.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obscene_Publications_Act_1857
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obscenity_trial_of_Ulysses_in_The_Little_Review