Building Better Monsters for 5E; Why Grinding Doesn’t Enhance the Fun and How To Fix It https://www.tabletopsentinel.com/columns/critical-hits-a-designer-s-perspective/building-better-monsters-for-5e

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 1 point 1 week ago

Increasing Armor Class: Why make attack rolls at all if the game is designed for you to hit at least seven of the ten times you roll the dice? The joy of a success is only satisfying if there’s a realistic chance of missing.

I would have gone the other way and just removed the two-hit check altogether. Missing isn't fun. Missing makes no progress. Get rid of it.

I don't think this would seriously solve the problems I have with DND. The adventuring day model is a huge source of problems. The inability to reason about much of the world (I see a knight on the road. How many hit points does he have? 10? 20? 200? This information would inform tactics but is not provided). Many other problems I don't feel like enumerating.

  • source