I don't know who this dude is. Sounds like a douche, but 1 year in the gym, you shouldn't expect crazy results unless you are juicing as well. I'm 3 years into getting back into lifting after a roughly 5 year gap, and I feel like I'm only barely getting to where I want to be with my physique. People think that working out will have you looking like Schwarzenegger after a year. That takes a lifetime with crazy diet and steroids. Damn near all of Hollywood juices to get their physiques these days. We shouldn't be comparing ourselves to that. It's basically the male equivalent of an anorexic model on meth.