Those American stats are bullshit based on self reporting, they are not apples to apples.
Numerous state controlled legally mandatory checks show that VW is the most reliable brand.
Here is the one from Denmark:

https://fdm.dk/nyheder/nyt-om-trafik-og-biler/tesla-skandalen-fortsaetter-naesten-hver-anden-tesla-model-y-dumper-til-syn

Similar tests from Germany, Netherlands and Sweden show the same.