columbia house was great; i was about 12 and got so many cds for a penny. no idea how it happened since i obviously had no bank account but not questioning
but really my dad had pretty much an entire wall of cds and cassettes in the 90s so i made so many mix tapes when i went to his house on the weekends. i guess thats kinda "pirating music" - at least as far as pre mp3s go.
also taping songs off the radio; i did that all the time to relisten to them along with recording my friends cassettes.
also we shared teddy ruxbin tapes like sugar.