Thank you, I think it is a very reasonable take. Not every asylum seekers have value that align with left-leaning ideology. It is hard to start this discussion without being labeled as right wing/nazi/racist.

I am an ex-muslim and also pretty damn left, but it is really hard to have a discussion on why Islam can be Bad. I put my hope for all the progressive muslims to change the culture surrounding the religion but considering how Islam works, I am not very optimistic it can change. We will see.

There is an important requirement toward assimilation into laws and some freedoms, I think, and I would love to see incoming refugees and migrants find a way to preserve their own beliefs while understanding where it doesn't match the belief structure of their new country and ready to work within the new environment.

This means very careful face-covering regs that respect religious demands on women but understands legal requirements for very discreet identification by 'approved' state reps -- and provides both education around it for everyone and people ready to bridge that gap.

And it also means better education around fraud and the freedom and responsibility to report it. And yes, I think that people mirating on a provisional basis - temporary/new status - need to know that their new countries don't accept the cut corners with a pay-out, that that it's our responsibility to report that stuff as proper citizens.

And yes, crime should remove the privileges of a temporary resident status. It's well-shown that immigrants are the most law-abiding people, on average, so this won't be a huge problem, but those who slip through the cracks can't stay and earn permanent status like that.

But it's nuanced. We need to deal with the hate toward immigration so it doesn't colour every interaction with refugees and migrants, and cause low-key distrust toward wonderful people. That's essentially racism, and it's not cool. I think we can let in people who like their new country and its rights and freedoms, while gently redirecting the people who can't assimilate properly where it matters (laws and rights, not directly religious and cultural). Some people are not a good fit to some host countries, and that needs to be assessed on a case basis, lest they indirectly germinate racism by their very discordant presence.

Unleash the downvotes. I'm sure I've offended droves of people who don't get that I am very pro-migration but cautiously so.

Are you no longer a communist over this? I don't really see how your stance on immigration is very related.