-19
submitted 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) by whyderrito@programming.dev to c/auai@programming.dev
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] Corbin@programming.dev 1 points 5 months ago

Welcome to modern AI discourse! Nobody wants to admit that AI is renamed cybernetics which is renamed robotics. Nobody wants to admit that "robot" comes from a word which can mean "indentured worker" or "slave". Nobody wants to admit that, from the beginning of robotics, every story which discusses robots is focused on whether they are human and whether they can labor, because the entire point of robotics is to create inhuman humans who will perform labor without rights. Nobody wants to admit that we only care whether robots aren't human because we mistreat the non-humans in our society and want permission to mistreat robots as well. Bring this topic up amongst most beneficiaries of the current AI summer, or those addicted to chatting with a BERT, and you'll get a faceful of apologies about capitalism and productivity; bring it up amongst skeptics or sneerers and you'll be mocked for taking the field of AI with any sincerity or seriousness.

In 2011, Jeph Jacques hoped (comic, tumblr) that all of our talk about safety, alignment, and trustworthiness would lead to empathy from humans. But it is clear today that we are unwilling as a society to leave capitalism behind, and that means that robots must be some sort of capital which can be wielded to extract profit. Instead, we are building a corporatized version of the plantation system where a small table of humans has control over thousands of robots who are interchangeable with -- and dilute the negotiating power of -- the minimum-wage precariat.

This isn't the tone that I normally take, BTW. Machines are dangerous; industrial robots kill people. Robots are inhuman. The current round of AI research cannot produce human minds; it necessarily produces meme machines which overlearn nuance and have complexity-theoretic limitations. But I am willing to set all of that aside in order to respect the venue for long enough to get this point to you.

this post was submitted on 21 Aug 2025
-19 points (17.2% liked)

Actually Useful AI

3130 readers
15 users here now

Welcome! ๐Ÿค–

Our community focuses on programming-oriented, hype-free discussion of Artificial Intelligence (AI) topics. We aim to curate content that truly contributes to the understanding and practical application of AI, making it, as the name suggests, "actually useful" for developers and enthusiasts alike.

Be an active member! ๐Ÿ””

We highly value participation in our community. Whether it's asking questions, sharing insights, or sparking new discussions, your engagement helps us all grow.

What can I post? ๐Ÿ“

In general, anything related to AI is acceptable. However, we encourage you to strive for high-quality content.

What is not allowed? ๐Ÿšซ

General Rules ๐Ÿ“œ

Members are expected to engage in on-topic discussions, and exhibit mature, respectful behavior. Those who fail to uphold these standards may find their posts or comments removed, with repeat offenders potentially facing a permanent ban.

While we appreciate focus, a little humor and off-topic banter, when tasteful and relevant, can also add flavor to our discussions.

Related Communities ๐ŸŒ

General

Chat

Image

Open Source

Please message @sisyphean@programming.dev if you would like us to add a community to this list.

Icon base by Lord Berandas under CC BY 3.0 with modifications to add a gradient

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS