I dunno, I know that legally we don’t know which way this is going to go, because the ai people presumably have very good lawyers
You're not wrong on the AI corps having good lawyers, but I suspect those lawyers don't have much to work with:
-
Pretty much every AI corp has been caught stealing from basically everyone (with basically everyone caught scraping without people's knowledge or consent, and OpenAI, Perplexity, and Anthropic all caught scraping against people's explicit wishes)
-
Said data was used to create products which, either implicitly or explicitly, produce counterfeits of the stolen artists' work
-
Said counterfeits are, in turn, destroying the artists' ability to profit from their original work and discouraging them from sharing it freely
-
And to cap things off, there's solid evidence pointing to the defendants being completely unrepentant in their actions, whether that be Microsoft's AI boss treating such theft as entirely acceptable or Mira Murati treating the job losses as an afterthought
If I were a betting man, I'd put my money on the trial being a bloodbath in the artists' favour, and the resulting legal precedent being one which will likely kill generative AI as we know it.