Hardly anything is evil. But most things are hungry. Hunger looks very like evil from the wrong end of the cutlery. Or do you think that your bacon sandwich loves you back?
- Doctor Who
Hardly anything is evil. But most things are hungry. Hunger looks very like evil from the wrong end of the cutlery. Or do you think that your bacon sandwich loves you back?
Most intelligent people realize after a few decades that if this is a created world then the creator is a sadist, and it's our moral duty to defy him, and be good, against the odds.
If it's not a created world, same duty still applies.
That's one way to see it, but using evil makes it sound supernatural and that's all BS. It's not evil but part of nature, evolved to niches. It's true that things live and die, including stars that gave up their elements for us to exist, and our DNA string survived all the extinction events. We're a way for the cosmos to know itself, as Sagan said. "You are not a drop in the ocean. You are the entire ocean in a drop." ― Rumi
Bad behavior in humans is due largely to the dualistic, unhealthy ways, poverty, abuse, ACE scores, and zero sum and punching down hierarchies that damage people.
GNU Sir Terry Pratchett.
So much wisdom in the Discworld series, I take a lot of my morality cues from it. Terry himself was very very angry about all the injustice in the world, but it helped make him into such a brilliant writer and delightful human being.
Immediately started reading this to the tune of the black parade..
That’s kinda fucked up, yo. Otters are very different from humans, even if we use the same words to describe parts of both.
The text doesn't say the otters are evil, it implies that the maker is evil for creating the system needing the suffering of the salmon to feed the otters.
But they are evil.
Then everyone who eats is evil.
Except for maybe gravel and rock.
That is the point. He is saying that the universe has evil inherently baked in because there are numerous organisms that need to kill others just to survive.
He is not saying the otters are evil themselves, but, that they must commit evil acts to survive. A truly benevolent God would create a world where organisms do not need to perform those acts.
While I agree with the last two sentences, the idea that we can see evil in otters acting on their survival instinct is very far fetched.
Only humans can be evil, and we know it when we see it. Our survival does not depend on being evil at all.
I’m a little curious as to why you say only humans can be evil?
Yeah, survival instincts are survival instincts; but eh, it is a harsh workd and that’s kinda what Prachet was getting at. It wasn’t that the otters were evil, the nature of the world that gave them those instincts is evil.
Though I’m not sure why they can’t be evil- for example when they rape other things to death. (Dolphins, too.)
We can exclude predators killing for their survival from being evil. That leaves killing and hurting for play, like a cat might do with a mouse he’s caught.
As far as I know, there are not that many animals that engage in that sort of thing. But to be evil, the cat has to have an understanding that he is unnecessarily hurting the mouse, and that it is wrong. Animals don’t have this kind of moral insight.
Are you sure cats don’t have that moral insight?
We’ve barely begun to scratch the surface on understanding what goes on in their heads, and we still aren’t even close to fully understanding what goes on in our own.
Edit- all that’s necessary is empathy, and cats have demonstrated that- every time they snuggle up to their human whose under the weather.
They can't, but you can. You can behold evil. But semantically it does not quite work to propose a philosophical question about if the cat or dolphin knows. It is futile sure but also what they are getting at is that without morals there is no evil. But there certainly is still evil. They just don't know they're evil. It's quite a non starter of a debate but still interesting.
cats.... what a fascinating choice to pick for this debate.
cats kill for pleasure, domestic cats especially because they don't need to feed on birds and other fauna. Billions of them.
https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms2380
I love my cat. I keep the murderer indoors lol. He's a good cat but I don't know that I'd hold him up for a paragon of moral insight, nor his species.
They make a great case, don't they?
though, we can't really say people are any better. I mean, we don't need to eat meat, but most of us really enjoy it. For cat's... they really don't have a choice on that, even if their food's harms get pushed out of sight. On the other hand, they also have crazy-strong predation instincts. I don't know that it's so much for fun, or if it's more like the firebug that compulsively sets things on fire and can't help it.
I wonder if the capable of acting on empathy to some degree is the secret sauce to what makes things sentient/sapient/"like us"
in any case, we genuinely don't know what goes on inside their heads. (especially the orange ones.)
Not sure at all. I should have used “as far as we know” throughout
If we define evil as harm + knowledge + choice, then the removal of one leg creates tragedy, mistake, or misfortune instead.
If there is no God (capital, G implies knowledge and choice), then there is no universal evil, only tragedy, misfortune, and the mistakes and evil acts of sentient beings, of which we are the only proven example (up for debate).
Doesn’t really answer the question…
I’ll ask again, how do you know otters lack the knowledge and choice (we know that they can do harm.)?
The otter could have used a rock to reduce the suffering if their meal, for example.
(Though maybe even as gruesome as it is, that’s a less-worse fate than what happens to salmon if they’re not predated upon. Literally digesting itself to death.)
I do not know (hence, the up for debate), but I can remain agnostic on otter sentence and leave the burden of proof to anyone claiming they are to others.
If they are, and revel in the wanton suffering of others, bathing in the dieing unborn of their prey for the joy of death, we can claim some otters are Evil I suppose.
I think there’s a bit of a misunderstanding when it comes to salmon eggs. They’re not unborn young if they’re still in the salmon because they’re not fertilized until after they’re laid. In this case no unborn young were killed. Otherwise we could say all unfertilized eggs we buy at the store are unborn young which we are killing. Or that every time a woman has her period she has a miscarriage because her body flushed out an egg.
The otters aren't evil. Whoever created the universe in such a way as to require suffering is evil.
all 32 comments