you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 11 points 1 day ago (2 children)

I think it's really interesting that people wanted to essentially invert the outcome of results from studies on plant intelligence and what that tells us about some animal intelligence.

If a study determines that a plant and a fruit fly have the same level of intelligence and sentience, your takeaway should be that fruit flies are not sentient and not that plants are. For some reason, many of our comrades took the incorrect outcome that was pushed by clickbait articles instead of spending a really long time reading all the research firsthand.

I think people don't want to admit that there is actually a line you can draw somewhere in the animal kingdom, because if you admit that there are animals that can't think and feel, it feels like you're conceding a philosophical argument to carnists. The very act of drawing that line feels so bad that people would rather think plants are sentient than admit that maybe a large chunk of invertebrates aren't. I personally think this is incorrect because sentience shouldn't determine whether a living being deserves our respect, but I understand why people have a strong reaction to these things.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 10 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    i hear there's debates about whatever barnacles or bivalves or something that have no nervous system and are incapable of feeling pain

    even if everybody thought it was cool to eat some of the bugs, capitalist mass farming of them would find some way to make it not ok by the strictest standard

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 8 points 1 day ago

    Yes, that's right. Bivalves don't have a central nervous system at all. They entirely lack the capability to receive, interpret, perceive, or react to pain, it literally does not exist to them. Scallops are the only member of the family for which there's any serious debate among professionals as to whether they can sense or experience anything at all.

    Scallops alone have a visual aspect to their reflexive nerves. It works similarly to the way a Venus fly trap uses sensory trichomes to detect contact. Their 200 eyes are basically just on/off light detectors that individually can detect the near field in front of them or the peripheral field further away. They're unbelievably complex eyes each with this array of square guanine crystals that project a field onto two separate retinas, and yet all the animal gets from it is basically just the ability to flinch based on light and dark. They have a grand total of three ganglia and they're remarkably electrically quiet compared to the nervous ganglia in a vertebrate animal.

    There's not a whole lot going on there, but the other bivalves have drastically less.

  • source
  • parent