I've had two medical-related companies call me on my cell phone and ask to verify my birthdate. There are legit companies I had business with.

When I refused, they give me no options (like call us back, or reply to an email, etc.), they are just in absolute hurry to get off the phone. The expectation is that I tell them my birthday and if I don't, they don't communicate with me.

It's outrageous to call someone and ask for information to verify them when you have a relationship with them, when the person's given you their phone number, and often there's a checkbox for "leave messages for me at this number. "

Other than the security aspect of handing out your birthday, who is going to be answering your phone? Family members and friends who are going to know your birthdate... it just seems so stupid..

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 12 points 8 hours ago* (2 children)

I actually once had to explain to some guy calling me from an actual bank that, no, I had no way to know for sure that he was indeed who he claimed he was and hence I wasn't going to give him personal identifying information to validate who I was which could be used by somebody to get into my bank account.

In fact I tried to get him to tell me something that only I and the bank knew (like how much money was in my account) to confirm his identity but he refused because "he couldn't confirm my identity so couldn't give me that information".

The whole thing was fucking ridiculous, sort of an IT Security version of a Comedy Sketch.

I then independently checked it (got the bank's contact number myself directly from their site) and indeed it had been a genuine call from the bank.

So, a fucking retail bank contacting their customers using the same format as a phishing call and actually expecting that people would give the random guy that just called them on the phone enough of their personal identifying data that the person on the other side could use it to access their bank account.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 8 points 5 hours ago (1 child)

    Just because they are calling from a bank number that still doesn't mean they are calling from a bank.

    Numbers are very easy to spoof. Only reasonably secure way is when you call them.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment