Selection of writings from the #anime tendency channel on the discord relating to why both left radicals and reactionaries are drawn to anime specifically, but most points are broadly applicable to other nerd cultures.
"There's probably a simple explanation tied to the fact that the folks with the most "extreme" ideologies are very online and often yeah, looking to escape whatever they view as wrong with society. Leftists recognizing what is actually wrong with society, and nazis thinking women that have sex a lot are the problem."
-MalikMistyRory
"setting aside shows with actual unique stories, and just focussing on the generic shows, I think anime as a genre is more anti fascist than fascist Seeing as most of the shows in the medium focus on escapism. So shows are not aimed at increasing political participation (one of the key components of a fascist movement) but rather decreasing it SoL shows and Isekai both have their origins in capitalist alienation, so like fascism, escapist anime are a response to late stage capitalism after an economic catastrophe but ultimately where fascist propaganda is a call to action (kill the ((((((enemy))))))) anime is a call to stay at home and consume media"
-ComradeRat
"I think generally anime is a very good medium for escapism. It's fantastical and you can get absorbed in other worlds and other lives. I use it for that quite often. But I understand it It's just escapism, and exactly zero of my problems would be fixed if I decided to try to move to Japan"
-Juxtaplicity
"ComradeRat: I've watched the episode a lot. I'm a huge sucker for any media that even hints at labour/left wing movements
Aphelion: I've noticed a lot of leftists are like this, obsessing over brief moments in media that are pro-left. I guess it serves as some form of escape, but to be fair left messages are quite rare.
ComradeRat: Definitely. I think it's just that when almost every media produced under capitalism implicitly or explicitly endorses the system, anything that's saying "no, this sucks" just stands out a lot And escapism is endemic to radical ideologies Horse shoe theory is dumb, but horse shoe anime profile pics theory is spot on tbh"
-ComradeRat and Aphelion