Written by: Steven Moffat

Directed by: Euros Lyn

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 4 points 1 month ago (1 child)

The first truly great episode of series 2, and unsurprisingly it's a Steven Moffat outing.

There's a lot of positive stuff to say here - the story structure is twisty without being convoluted, Sophia Myles is pitch-perfect as Reinette, and heck, even Ben Turner's King Louis is pretty good. And of course, the clockwork men that harvest human organs are that combination of cool-yet-terrifying-in-a-childish-sort-of-way that Moffat excels at.

Tennant is at his swashbuckling best - I've said it before, but I really enjoy him as the romantic hero. And Rose apparently got all jealousy out of her system last episode, so there's none of that hanging over our heads this time around.

Speaking of Rose, I think they hit a good balance of enthusiasm for the adventure early on in the episode, constrasted with Mickey's nerves. It reinforces my notion that "Tooth and Claw" should have come later in the season, to show an increasing disregard for the seriousness of their situations. As it is, I think that one's still a bit of an outlier.

It's a little odd that Mickey says he got a spaceship on his "first go," but also references a previous adventure with Cleopatra. Maybe this is his "first go" to the future, rather than the past? I should really check to see if he and Rose changed clothes between episodes, but...nah.

They didn't bother shoehorning a "Torchwood" reference into this one, which is probably for the best.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 1 month ago

    Agreed about Rose's jealousy.

    On Rose and Mickey get along really well - it felt a bit too quick after her pouting at the end of last time. Given what I remember happening over the course of the remaining episodes, they should have done a bit more to cement Mickey's place on the team, rather than it feeling like he's just there for a little bit. That Cleopatra episode sounds like it would make a nice story of its own.

    Doctor as the "Romantic Hero" does work well. On the actual romance itself, I tried to ignore the whole "I met you as a 10-year old just as many minutes ago".

  • source
  • parent