you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 0 points 1 year ago (2 children)

I fully agree that if it comes down to “left to right”

It never does

But I’ve just shown why that “rule” is a common part

No you didn't. You showed you didn't understand the rules. Doing addition first for 10-1+1 is 10+1-1, not 10-(1+1). It literally means add all positive numbers together first, which are +10 and +1, as per Maths textbooks...

Note in the above simplification of the coefficients we have 6-11+5-7+2=6+5+2-11-7=13-18=-5, and not, as you claim 6-(11+5)-(7+2)=6-16-9=-19

because it is so weird and quite esoteric

It's a convention, not a rule, and as such can be completely ignored by those who understand the rules. See literal textbook example

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago (1 child)

    I know it's not a rule, hence why I put it in quotation marks. I noted in another comment that, yes, the proper way is to group it as 1+(-2)+3 and you can do it in any order. What I meant with ""rule"" is the meme questions pray on people not understanding/remembering what the actual rules are or why "left to right" conventions exist.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 0 points 1 year ago*

    the proper way is to group it as 1+(-2)+3

    No it isn't.

    you can do it in any order

    You can do it in any order anyway

    left to right 1-2+3=-1+3=2

    addition first 1+3-2=4-2=2

    subtraction first -2+1+3=-1+3=2

    right to left 3-2+1=1+1=2

    What I meant with ““rule”” is the meme questions pray on people not understanding/remembering what the actual rules are

    And you showed that you were one of them. Every answer you got other than 4 was wrong, because you didn't understand the rules. spoiler alert: doing it in different orders never means add brackets to it. Addition first for 10-1+1 is 10+1-1, not 10-(1+1). See previous textbook example

    why “left to right” conventions exist

    They exist because people like you make mistakes when you try to do it in a different order. Either learn how the rules work or stop spreading disinformation. Well, you should stop spreading disinformation regardless.

  • source
  • parent