103
Hexbear Meta Open-Floor Post
(hexbear.net)
Hexbear Meta Community
Posts should be a a Proposal (idea for changing the site), Feedback (regarding non-technical aspects of the site, for technical please use https://hexbear.net/c/feedback), or Appeals (regarding admin/moderator actions).
Discussion regarding these will be within comments under the post, appeals and feedback that is resolve may be removed as well as duplicate posts.
The following behavior will result in mod action:
People that are frequently making vague posts or comments.
People that are hostile, taking the least charitable interpretation or engaging in bad-faith
People that are maliciously trying to stir up drama
Systems of moderation for forums like this necessarily need to be a bit arbitrary and, for this forum in particular, very opaque. This creates a situation where the users' trust in the moderation team becomes a critical resource for the community. In my admittedly vibes-based analysis this trust, while still relatively high, is at an all-time low.
Trust is generated over time, but this site being populated mostly by different varieties of contrarians and malcontents seems to make generating trust pretty inefficient. I suspect even moderately big reforms for accountability or whatever will be seen as empty attempts at legitimation. Of course, trust will still need to be spent from time to time, but before any reforms, I would make sure internally that it isn't being wasted. To make this a little less uselessly abstract, for example (chosen randomly, please do not take this as a complaint about this case in particular), punishing users for upvoting a pretty bad post probably isn't worth it from the perspective of trust.
You can just say leftists/communists/socialists
Hoping to start towards rebuilding that trust with this post, and we will not be punishing hexbear users for only upvoting posts, but we do use it in conjunction with other mod tools to inform our systems of moderation.
Should be a tagline