675
Nuclear isn't perfect, but it is the best we have right now. (lemmy.world)
submitted 2 years ago by to c/memes@lemmy.ml
582 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 4 points 2 years ago (3 children)

The above comment have been deleted so I cannot judge what was said

But, as a french person myself, I can assure you that the state of Nuclear Energy in France is a very complicated topic and you do yourself a disservice talking about it in this fashion

Furthermore, what you state is plainly wrong:

  • France export more than import energy

  • Nuclear Power plant goes down first on the network because there are more "pilotable" meaning you can start it or reduce their output more easily than others sources of electrical power

  • the caping of electricity price is a leftist policy, the right has nothing to do with it and in fact, this is an another very complicated topic that needs to be researched before discussing

  • France economy is instable right now yes, but pinning this on government debt is surely a drastic oversimplification of the problem and is more telling of your view of my Country than the effective state of our economy

  • permalink
  • fedilink
  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
    •
  • [–] 4 points 2 years ago (2 children)

    The above comment have been deleted so I cannot judge what was said

    Are you sure? I can still read it? It downplayed the top level comment and said the French have the cheapest electricity because of 'cheap' nuclear power production.

    Furthermore, what you state is plainly wrong:

    • France export more than import energy

    No I am not. I stated that the need for importing energy is dangerously high when the nuclear plants are offline. The averaged annual export / import balance is a different number. Comparing both doesn't make sense. Additional France WAS a net exporter. 2022 it was importing more than exporting. Here is a source:

    https://www.euractiv.com/section/electricity/news/electricity-exporter-for-42-years-france-became-a-net-importer-in-2022/

    Nuclear Power plant goes down first on the network because there are more "pilotable" meaning you can start it or reduce their output more easily than others sources of electrical power

    Well, I think, gas goes down first. But anyway this is unrelated to my comment. I was talking about shutdowns due to technical issues and repairments. The larger one 2022 is also the reason why the ex/import balance shifted. Just as I claimed.

    https://www.france24.com/en/france/20220825-france-prolongs-shutdown-of-nuclear-reactors-over-corrosion-amid-rising-energy-prices

    the caping of electricity price is a leftist policy, the right has nothing to do with it

    Sure it's a leftist policy. I didn't say it was a right wing policy. I said it was implemented to dampen the effects on inflation. Rising prices fueled (and still fuels) fears in the population which the right wing parties happily exploit.

    France economy is instable right now yes, but pinning this on government debt is surely a drastic oversimplification of the problem and is more telling of your view of my Country than the effective state of our economy

    I didn't pinned down anything myself. The concerns of economists and the EU are indeed about France fiscal deficits. The EU started a penalty process just a few days ago because of it

    https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/19/business/france-budget-deficit-macron.html

    France is in debt to the tune of around €3 trillion, or more than 110 percent of gross domestic product, and a deficit of €154 billion, representing 5.5 percent of economic output. The budget crunch comes after Mr. Macron spent heavily to support workers and businesses during pandemic lockdowns. His government also provided subsidies to help households cope with a jump in inflation after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which sent energy prices soaring.

    but pinning this on government debt is surely a drastic oversimplification of the problem and is more telling of your view of my Country than the effective state of our economy

    Next time when calling someone 'plainly wrong' try using sources and arguments instead of an ad hominem

  • permalink
  • fedilink
  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
    •
  • [–] 8 points 2 years ago (1 child)

    Are you sure? I can still read it?

    Yeah, it's say's it was deleted by the creator, anyway that not what's important here

    No I am not. I stated that the need for importing energy is dangerously high when the nuclear plants are offline.

    You've stated :

    Your nuclear plants are most of the time turned off because they aren’t working properly which destabilizes the entire European grid because you need to import so much electricity from your neighbours.

    The way your statement is worded imply this is a common occurrence when I'm fact it is usually the other way around, France supply a lot of energy to it's neighbors

    Additional France WAS a net exporter. 2022 it was importing more than exporting.

    Yes in 2022 a year spectacularly weird for energy production everywhere in Europe thanks to the Ukrainian situation

    But in 2023 France export more than import again Source : https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2024/01/17/la-france-est-redevenue-premiere-exportatrice-d-electricite-en-europe-en-2023_6211385_3234.html

    But anyway this is unrelated to my comment. I was talking about shutdowns due to technical issues and repairments. The larger one 2022 is also the reason why the ex/import balance shifted. Just as I claimed.

    It's not clear from your text than this was your original intention

    I said it was implemented to dampen the effects on inflation. Rising prices fueled (and still fuels) fears in the population which the right wing parties happily exploit.

    No you did not say that, you said:

    The only reason why your electricity is still so cheap is because your nuclear plants are so heavily subsidised by the state and the exploding energy prices in the recent past have also been capped by the state fearing the right wing uprise.

    Inflation doesn't appear in your text

    Furthermore, even if you say that now, the capping of electricity prices are not only to combat inflation, but yes it is a reason, one other is to prevent private company to dictate the price of electricity, as an "essential" it's important that every one in the country can afford electricity, it's the same thing here for medication for exemple, state chose the price for almost every medicine you can buy in France

    I didn't pinned down anything myself. The concerns of economists and the EU are indeed about France fiscal deficits. The EU started a penalty process just a few days ago because of it

    That's can be an entire new discussion (that I will not engage here, because I'm, and I think you too, as almost everyone, have not all the keys to discuss it) but economists say's a lot of things about this subject and forget that's France is it's own country and by that, have it's own way of thinking about debt, for many french leftist economists (not all obviously), debt is a good thing for exemple and that impact the way we use and think gouvernement funding

    If you're interested I can link you to some resources on the question (albeit in french sorry)

    PS: Sadly as I'm rereading my message, I'm realizing that the tone of it is harsher than I want it to be, buy I don't have the time or the energy to rewrite it in a more tasteful maner, sorry again

  • permalink
  • fedilink
  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
    •