Why isn’t that incident enough for everyone to drop them?
There is no public email service provider -as far as I know- that would refuse a court order to share such information. In the case of Proton any foreign authority wanting such needs to convince Swiss authorities that their request is legitimate.
Ultimately if you register an account with false credentials & never pay for pro, then the only thing proton can give to Swiss authorities is maybe your IP address, which will be your VPN if you have one. If you pay then payment credentials could be used to identify you.
All the emails stored on proton's servers are non-recoverable, same as with Tuta.
It sucks that paying for pro reduces your privacy, but this applies to other email providers as well. This is actually what happened in the Atlanta case & there is no real defense against it. Using your personal credit card creates a trail.
Can you imagine a world where you can order physical cards for email credit? (and they would have randomized codes to avoid this exact problem)
Did he make a post defending the asterisk “privacy first” should have in their marketing?
Private email is a bit of an oxymoron, the best anyone can do is to store your own email history in an unrecoverable way, which proton is doing, but their marketing team is not really transparent about what "private email" really is & what that means to users.
