301
AlternativeTo: a resource I wish I would have had when I started using Linux
(alternativeto.net)
Funniest thing is they have a page for alternatives to their own site
this post was submitted on 29 Aug 2024
301 points (95.7% liked)
Open Source
31385 readers
148 users here now
All about open source! Feel free to ask questions, and share news, and interesting stuff!
Useful Links
- Open Source Initiative
- Free Software Foundation
- Electronic Frontier Foundation
- Software Freedom Conservancy
- It's FOSS
- Android FOSS Apps Megathread
Rules
- Posts must be relevant to the open source ideology
- No NSFW content
- No hate speech, bigotry, etc
Related Communities
Community icon from opensource.org, but we are not affiliated with them.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Practicing what you preach. Right on...
meta af. Kinda like how liberapay funds itself with its own model.
I figured OSalt would have been near the top of the recommendations. I didn't realize how unpopular it was I guess. It's a little more selective in it's recommendations (and perhaps a tad dated).
Happy to see it get love and spread the word. alternativeto.net is my go to. Worthy of muscle memory. I've also found great options in the awesome lists on github. Especially awesome self-hosted if we're talking software. I thought I remember an alternativeto-like site geared towards cli, but I couldn't find it last time I looked. LMK if that rings a bell for anyone.
I always thought this and all the other sites like it were just SEO bait. The quality of the alternatives is no better than random, though I guess you can discover software you didn't know existed. One example: I'm always looking for an alternative to Roon. Like Plex for music, plus you can add in tidal or qobuz, so you can essentially listen to anything on your own library, or the streaming services, from anywhere. It also has an incredible metadata system, letting you view for example, all the players on a jazz album, view bios of every one, and easily start to check out some new music that way. It's unbelievably flawed and poorly run though.
What is alternativeto.net's suggestion as a replacement? Fucking VLC Media player. The only real contender is PlexAmp, or if you want something similar but only for classical music (and without self hosting your own library), there's idagio. results like that make me think it's totally useless
AlternativeTo is crowdsource, so one individual might find software A as suitable alternative, while others are not.
The same way that some people find GIMP enough to replace Photoshop, while others prefer Affinity Photo, Paint.NET, or Photopea.
I personally find so many cool underrated FOSS software, such as Inochi2D, AB Download Manager, Miria, OpenUTAU, Our Paint, Mihon, and Wick Editor.
This is also my experience. The results are usually very vaguely related with what I search. I had better luck with Wikipedia comparison tables, but often they are incomplete.
Yeah it seems mostly SEO bait whenever I get results for it. I mostly rely on "awesome" lists on GitHub to find actual alternatives.
Yeah, I have not once seen anything of value in their "alternatives", they always show the weirdest shit that has nothing in common with the other. It's been in my Kagi block list from the very beginning, I don't miss those results one bit.
It's mostly that it's just an older site and the voting/review system goes back by over a decade. Much of the information you're gonna get on there is just dated, pure and simple, and that reflects in the rankings.
And as you said, the categories aren't curated well enough. Too many unrelated suggestions.
It is actually useful?
In my experience it just looked like SEO farm that polluted my search results with irrelvant machine-generated content.
Totally. I often go directly to it to find applications.
It's how I found kdenlive, it's how I found audiobookshelf, etc.
Guess I should give it a proper look, then.
Yep! There are so also many niche applications people never heard.
I regularly checking it for any FOSS alternative to any closed-source software. For example: Inochi2D, AB Download Manager, Miria, OpenUTAU, Our Paint, and Wick Editor.
How do you think relevant search results get to you?
Only issue with alternativeto is the comments and reviews are all dated, some by over 10 years, and often don't reflect the current state of the software.
A lot of the information on the site just feels very stale in general.
So leave a new one.
For that, one should test all the software personally.
Of course if you use something with only the old reviews, leave a new one! But the fact is, utility of the service is often dampened due to this fact.
That's not really how the comments on alternativeto work. They are relative.
If you got to spotifys page, it will list similar services, each with their own comments, and the comments under youtube music, for example, will be about how it compares to spotify.
So, to leave useful comments, you only have to know how a given piece of software compares to what you used before. You don't comment on how a given thing compares to everything else, only to one thing at a time.
Then, as other people browse the alternatives, they can use those individual comparisons to navigate their way to what they need. Stuff like "this can't replace that for this use-case, because reason, but it does this other stuff" is extremely useful when looking for something that does what you're looking for.
Slant.co used to be similarly useful before its company shut it down to focus on Vetted.ai... Less useful though since almost every outgoing link was an affiliate or ad link. Alternativeto.net has been kinda the best option since the late 00s
Wikipedia can also be useful to find software - e.g.:
- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_vector_graphics_editors
- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_integrated_development_environments
- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_audio_player_software
or look at the Wikipedia page for whatever you want to replace and see if it's in a category such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Audio_editing_software_for_Linux
You can even do this with things that aren't software, e.g. Homebase -> UK home improvement stores -> Screwfix.
I really appreciate Open Source Alternative To for this (although their theme seems a little broken atm).
The best thing I have found on there:
How to navigate F-Droid and the huge number of apps.
https://alternativeto.net/list/28655/the-ultimate-f-droid-setup/
*disclaimer: I am not the author of this list
Thanks for the links, something I have not really thought about. I pretty much assume very low security/privacy on all modern smartphones anyway(commercial or FLOSS ecosystems).
F-Droid is a handy way to find and support devs who are sharing their expertise.
Certainly, use the download-channels that you are comfortable with.
As mentioned on that page, F-Droid and IzzyOnDroid can link you to many decent FLOSS apps. It's an easy way to be exposed to a large amount of free software.